Analyst Report: FSLR

First Solar, Inc. (FSLR) shares plummeted -10.18% on January 29, 2026, driven by a renewed and credible competitive threat from Tesla (TSLA). During Tesla’s Q4 2025 earnings call on January 28, CEO Elon Musk announced an aggressive push into solar manufacturing, targeting 100 GW of annual production—a scale that dwarfs First Solar's current capacity. This unexpected pivot, coupled with a subsequent downgrade from BMO Capital Markets, shattered investor confidence in First Solar's "moat" as the premier U.S. solar manufacturer. The market is pricing in a structural shift in the competitive landscape, fearing that Tesla's vertical integration could erode First Solar's pricing power and market share long-term.

The sharp decline was triggered by two specific, interlinked events:

1. Tesla Q4 Earnings Call (Jan 28, 2026, Post-Market):

   • Elon Musk explicitly stated that the "solar opportunity is underrated" and confirmed Tesla is working toward 100 gigawatts (GW) per year of solar cell production.
   • He emphasized a strategy of full vertical integration, from raw materials to finished panels, directly challenging First Solar's vertically integrated thin-film model.
   • This commentary marked a shift from vague aspirations to what analysts now perceive as a concrete capital commitment.

2. BMO Capital Downgrade (Jan 29, 2026, Pre-Market):

   • Analyst: Ameet Thakkar (BMO Capital).
   • Action: Downgraded FSLR from Outperform to Market Perform.
   • Price Target Cut: Reduced from $285 to $263.
   • Rationale: BMO noted that while they had previously dismissed Musk's solar ambitions as "aspirational," the specific commentary on the call suggests this is now a "bona fide endeavor." The firm warned that this creates a long-term overhang on FSLR shares, as Tesla's entry could dilute First Solar's dominance in the domestic module market.

• Official Name: First Solar, Inc.
• Ticker: FSLR (NASDAQ)
• Core Business: First Solar is a leading American solar technology company and global provider of comprehensive photovoltaic (PV) solar energy solutions. Unlike competitors using crystalline silicon, FSLR uses proprietary Cadmium Telluride (CdTe) thin-film semiconductor technology.
• Sector: Technology / Semiconductors (Solar Energy)
• Market Cap: ~$26.7 Billion (post-drop estimate)
• Key Competitors: Canadian Solar, JinkoSolar, Enphase Energy (in broader ecosystem), and now emerging as a direct manufacturing rival: Tesla.
• Performance Context:
  • YTD: Down significantly following the Jan 29 drop.
  • 52-Week Range: Highly volatile; recently trading near ~$270 before this correction.
  • Recent Earnings: Q3 2025 (reported Oct 30, 2025) showed EPS of $4.24. Q4 2025 Earnings are scheduled for February 24, 2026.

Is this move justified? The -10% drop reflects a repricing of terminal value rather than immediate earnings risk. First Solar has been the darling of the Inflation Reduction Act (IRA), benefiting immensely from Section 45X tax credits for domestic manufacturing. The "Bull Case" for FSLR relied on it being the only scalable U.S. option for utility-grade projects.

• The Bear Argument: Tesla's entry destroys the "scarcity premium" FSLR commands. If Tesla achieves even 50% of its 100 GW target, it would flood the market with domestic panels, crushing the Average Selling Price (ASP) and eroding FSLR's margins. The market is also reacting to the "Musk Factor"—his ability to disrupt industries (like auto and space) is not being bet against.
• The Bull Counter: Tesla has a history of missing aggressive timelines ("Elon time"). Building 100 GW of capacity will take years, likely not impacting supply dynamics until 2028+. First Solar has a multi-year backlog of contracted orders (over 50 GW) that insulates it from immediate price shocks. The sell-off may be a knee-jerk overreaction to a distant threat.

Sector Context: Solar stocks were already under pressure in January 2026 due to broader tech/software slides and "de-booking" fears (customers cancelling orders). Jefferies had downgraded FSLR earlier in the month (Jan 7) citing "limited booking visibility," creating a fragile sentiment environment that exacerbated the reaction to the Tesla news.

• Price Action: The stock gapped down significantly at the open on Jan 29, breaking below the 50-day moving average.
• Support Levels:
  • Immediate Support: $215 - $220 (Recent consolidation zone).
  • Critical Floor: $195 (200-day moving average or prior major breakout level).
• Resistance: $245 - $250 (The gap fill level from the Jan 29 drop).
• Volume: Heavy. The drop occurred on significantly elevated volume (over 2x average daily volume), indicating institutional distribution and "risk-off" behavior.
• Pattern: The chart now shows a potential "Head and Shoulders" top formation if the $215 support fails to hold.

• Execution Risk (Tesla): If Tesla breaks ground on a mega-factory in Q1/Q2 2026, FSLR sentiment will worsen.
• Policy/Tariff Uncertainty: The BMO note highlighted risks around Section 232 tariffs. If the U.S. government grants exclusions (carve-outs) for imported polysilicon/modules to keep project costs low, FSLR's pricing advantage diminishes.
• Upcoming Earnings (Feb 24, 2026): The Q4 report is a "binary event." A miss on guidance or confirming "de-bookings" would validate the Jefferies bear thesis and could send the stock below $200.
• Interest Rates: High rates continue to squeeze project developers, potentially leading to further order cancellations.

• Short-Term (1-2 Weeks): Avoid / Neutral. Expect high volatility. The stock is "in the penalty box" until the shock of the Tesla news is digested. We may see a "dead cat bounce" to ~$235, but sellers are likely to remain active.
• Medium-Term (1-3 Months): Watch Earnings Closely. The February 24th earnings call is the next major catalyst. Management must address the Tesla threat and provide strong 2026 guidance to stabilize the stock. If they guide weak, the drift lower continues.
• Long-Term Thesis: Under Review. The fundamental thesis of FSLR as the sole beneficiary of U.S. solar industrial policy is broken. While FSLR remains a high-quality manufacturer with a strong balance sheet, the "moat" is no longer undisputed. Investors should demand a wider margin of safety (lower entry price) to account for the new competitive reality.

Analyst Rating: HOLD (Downgraded from Buy confidence). Target Entry: $205 - $210 for a contrarian trade.

• firstsolar.com
• fool.com
• utilitydive.com
• zacks.com
• stocktitan.net
• moomoo.com
• tipranks.com
• marketbeat.com
• barchart.com
• nasdaq.com